The Starting Lineup – Fan Favorite Cookie Box

These aren’t just cookies. They’re the ones with a fan club.
We took your most-ordered, most-raved-about, most-can't-stop-thinking-about-it cookies and packed them into one legendary 6-pack.

The Starting Line-Up is for the real ones—the repeat buyers, the gift givers, the “I’ll take the usual” crowd.

🍪 One each of:

• Banana Pudding

• Reese’s Brownie

• Cookie Butter S’mores

• Strawberry Crunch

• Red Velvet Cookies & Cream

• Birthday Cake

📦 6-pack only – fixed lineup, no swaps (allergy exceptions only!)
💖 Fan-tested, cookie-lover approved
🚚 Ships nationwide 
✨ The box you reach for when you want the good stuff

No fluff. Just favorites.

Shipping cost is based on weight. Just add products to your cart and use the Shipping Calculator to see the shipping price.We want you to be 100% satisfied with your purchase. Items can be returned or exchanged within 30 days of delivery.